

When I was a kid, we could still play 78 albums. 8-tracks were the norm, cassette tapes were just entering the market, and we had 1 color tv, which was in the den. So my brothers and I listened to a lot of music albums in our basement and used our imaginations to dance and pretend. One album in particular was our favorite, one my mom had in the 40s when 78 albums were cutting edge. Bugs Bunny hunting sheep (not wabbits). We would act it out, trapping some innocent little lambs. Our favorite line was soon to come: how are you Bugs Bunny someone asked? Whether the lamb was stuffed inside him or actually eaten, I was never sure. But Bugs answered clear as day, "not b-a-a-a-a-a-a-d!" We would roar in laughter and play it and shout it over and over. We actually still do.
This
Basil Crusted Leg of Lamb with Lemon Vinaigrette recipe is fanta-a-a-a-a-stic. As victorious as Bugs must have felt in pinning his conquest, I felt I conquered a difficult recipe and produced a perfectly prepared leg of lamb worthy to serve to the Warner Brothers themselves.
I started by visiting what is considered the best butcher in town. Sadly, the town of Westfield has no butchers, when some residents can remember up to three. I googled "Westfield butcher" to make sure I wasn't overlooking anyone. When the first entry is Omaha Steaks and the second entry is Westfield Seafood, I knew I had to invoke the "within 5-miles" rule to advance in my cooking project. So I drove 3.5 miles to Scotch Plains and took my first step into the reputable
John's Meat Market. I was greeted by 3 guys cutting huge slabs of legs, sides and shoulders. Yet for some reason I felt completely safe.
John's is run by the original proprietor's sons Vinnie & Nick. In my brief time at the store, I learned they had recently been voted
NJ Monthly's Best Butcher. I was told that the dollar is no good in New Zealand, so now they get their lamb from Colorado. And that they split their purchases with Peter Luger's buyer at the 14th Street meat market.
With personality, quality cuts of beef and a booming take out business, it's no wonder John's has been in the hood for over 70 years. I walked out with a butterflied leg of lamb, a promise to return for the turkey chili, and 4 new friends. I can't wait to return. They claim to be like Cheers, where everybody know's their name. I hope that is true.
I prepared the lamb a day in advance. I stopped by
Trader Joe's for the rest of the recipe's ingredients. Trader Joe's sells dry toasted pine nuts which spares me from toasting and/or burning the nuts myself. I knew I had a plain white bagel at home so I toasted that instead of buying a new loaf of white. I had the oil, garlic, lemon and coarse sea salt at home. I substituted crushed red pepper for cayenne. Grabbed a package of fresh thyme, a bottle of syrah and headed home to tie up a few loose ends.
Before you start this recipe, it is helpful to lay down 6 pieces of kitchen twine that are about 8" each, and lay the lamb down lengthwise over the twine, fat side down. Prepare the basil mixture in a food processor - a wedding gift that is getting more action this week than during the 8 year span of my marriage. All this cooking seems to have the same effect...OK, so you combine all the ingredients, pulse a few times and spread it on the lamb. You guess what is next - tie up the sucker real tight and stick in a gallon size zip lock overnight.
The rule follower I am not, I had a hard time sticking to this recipe to the letter, like I'm supposed to. It was the night I prepared the pie crust for the tomato tart. A rare 30 minutes to myself on a gorgeous spring evening. I could have done anything, but I chose to silently, and without interruption, cook. I quietly prepared my dough and browned my lamb between dropping off and picking up my 2 girls. Rather than browning the lamb in a flameproof roasting pan, I grilled over high heat on the barbecue. As you can see, there was no flameproofing. I guess I was feeling a bit rebellious and ambitious.
Later than evening, I roasted the lamb for 1 1/4 hours and then opened it, topped it with additional basil mixture, and broiled it to sizzling perfection. I had it for lunch the next day, and my seven year old neighbor ate most of what I left for his mom. My husband loved the lemon dijon vinaigrette. I am waiting for the next big chance to make this - and shop at John's - again very soon.